What Defines America’s Team
Thursday, July 9, 2009
Mark Schlereth and James Hasty offer their take on the “America’s Team” debate.
To the credit of Bobby Ryan whom coined the Dallas Cowboys as ‘America’s Team’ from 1978 highlights videos it remains a debate as to which NFL team should actually be awarded the honor.
With continious playoff standings and key marketing the Cowboys have continued to boast the title and stay in America’s focus by partaking in Thanksgiving Day and continual Monday Night Football appearances.
No other team has more fans that identify with the Cowboys. With no other team can you travel to an away game and find so many fans in the apposing teams city. It was and has been a bandwagon since the Cowboys glory days.
6 Responses to “What Defines America’s Team”
Leave a Reply
Custom Authentic Jerseys social media advertising by iePlexus.com.
Entries (RSS) and Comments (RSS).
The views, opinions and information are unofficial, independent and are not otherwise affiliated or represent the views or opinions of Custom Authentic Jerseys not any team, league or orgonization.
Entries (RSS) and Comments (RSS).
The views, opinions and information are unofficial, independent and are not otherwise affiliated or represent the views or opinions of Custom Authentic Jerseys not any team, league or orgonization.





July 9th, 2009 at 6:19 pm
I don’t think the Steelers would fit America’s Team.
Now before you jump on me, hear me out.
I have met a lot of Pittsburgh fans, and the one thing I notice is they are from Pittsburgh.
The reason Dallas was America’s team was because they had fans in away stadiums that weren’t necessarily from Texas.
They had Roger Staubach and Tom Landry, who represented the ultimate good guys. It was really made to take the sting out of a Super Bowl loss to none other than Pittsburgh. There was something about that star that symbolized America, like the stars on the flag. Black and gold is not part of the American flag like blue and white are.
The Steelers are too Pittsburgh to be called America, and that is better for them because the United States is not all blue collar steel workers.
America’s team no, but they have my vote for the working man’s team any day, and that is why I respect them so much. I just can’t see them representing anything but the great people of Pittsburgh.
July 9th, 2009 at 6:19 pm
The “America’s Team” thing is a myth and b.s. in my humble opinion. A 6th Super Bowl title will make the Steelers undisputably the best NFL franchise in the Super Bowl Era. With 12 – yes twelve – NFL titles, including 3 Super Bowl championships, the Green Bay Packers stand alone in terms of the entire history of the league. By the way, the New York Giants have 7 titles (4 NFL, 3 Super Bowls). And the Dallas Cowboys also have 5 Super Bowl wins.
July 9th, 2009 at 6:49 pm
Being nicknamed America’s Team is not about the number of titles won. If you look back in the 70’s the Steelers had 4 SB titles to the Cowboys’ 2 yet the media, key word here, kept referring to the Cowboys as America’s Team simply based on the fact that the Cowboys were selling out stadiums wherever they played and had big time stars on their team. It also didn’t hurt that they played in the 3rd largest media market and were constantly promoted by Tex Schramm. The Steelers, in the meantime, played and still do in one of the smaller media markets in the NFL so that limited their chances of being shown to a national audience. All four of these teams have great fans bases and all four of these teams have bandwagon jumpers. Steelers fans don’t pretend there aren’t any jumpers in your midst, they’re among you. 10 years ago you had to look high and low for a Pats fan, now they’re all over the place. The Steelers have Steeler Nation but that’s not really their moniker since they ripped off of the Raiders. A case that can be made for the Cowboys being called America’s Team is that they ellicit a reaction either positively or negatively. People either hate the Cowboys or love them, there is no in-between. I don’t encounter that in coversations about the Steelers, Patriots, or Packers. In today’s world with so much media coverage no one team can really be called America’s Team. Just my humble two cents worth.
July 9th, 2009 at 6:49 pm
There is no debate. In order to have a debate, there must be two contradictory positions which can each be reasonably argued. That is not the case here. The Dallas Cowboys are America’s Team. Period. End of discussion.
That said, when Bob Ryan of NFL Films first gave the nickname to the Cowboys, Tom Landry didn’t like it or want it. Because he knew it would put a huge target on the team, which is exactly what happened.
But it goes far beyond that. The Cowboys have always been a target. When they came into the league, they stole the southern television market from the Washington Redskins and the limelight from the New York Giants, which of course in media circles is an unforgivable sin. So the Cowboys are always going to be criticized for that.
Moreover, the Cowboys came in with their flashy white uniforms and fancy Blue Stars, which look better on television, as well as their defensive and offensive innovations. They were the new finesse team, as opposed to the old tough teams like the Browns, the Packers, the Colts and the Steelers. This is why the NFL could not allow Dallas to win against Cleveland or Green Bay or Baltimore or Pittsburgh. The fix was in, and the refs made sure of it. (See the Ice Bowl and Super Bowls V, X and XII, if you doubt the Conspiracy. Same thing happened in 94 when the league was simply not going to allow Dallas to win 3 Super Bowls in a row.)
But I think a lot of Cowboy hatred has to do with the assassination of Kennedy in Dallas. This cannot be discounted. Read the players’ accounts of how they were treated at away games in the aftermath. Hotel staff refusing to unload their luggage, the threats and insults hurled at them by opposing fans and players both. Even Staubach, then playing at Navy, when he went up against the University of Texas, was told in no uncertain terms, “You have to beat these guys, they killed Kennedy.”
So there’s a lot that goes into the mix. The Cowboys are America’s Team because they look best on television, which attracts a wide fan base, but also because they got beat, they got robbed, and they didn’t quit. They kept coming back every year until they won, and they kept winning. That defines America, and that defines America’s Team.
They’re hated because they’re popular, because they look good and because they win. But they’re also hated because they displaced some of the older teams, and because a lot of people still to this day blame the city of Dallas for the assassination of Kennedy. It’s a blessing and a curse. But then that’s America, just as much as it is America’s Team.
July 9th, 2009 at 6:50 pm
Google America’s Team – http://www.google.com/#hl=en&q=America’s+Team – Cowboys are number 3 just under wikipedia which states:
- end of discussion
July 9th, 2009 at 6:51 pm
The “America’s Team” moniker came from NFL films. As a die hard Steeler fan of 38 years all’s I can say is, “We don’t need no steenking America’s Team moniker.” We know where our team stands in the mix of things and we’re dam proud. The Rooney’s put up an honest football team. You know what you are going to get when you go to Pittsburgh. They’ve built an organization that values character and excellence and the love of the game. Jerry Jones is not one to shun the limelight. He is a savvy businessman and does not miss a beat to market his brand. “America’s Team” was a gift for the Dallas Cowboys and Mr. Jones did not miss a beat in using it. Having players like TO and their ilk only puts the spotlight on Dallas more than they would otherwise deserve. I’m sure Jones loves it. Pittsburgh doesn’t need another nickname because they are The Steelers.